IN THE NAME OF ALLAH, THE MOST BENEFICENT, THE MOST MERCIFUL
IMRAN SHAYKH, APR 2017
FEEDBACK

1- Bahais and Compulsory Education
Abdul Baha had insisted that all people everywhere should be educated using the exact same manner and system:

It is necessary that the guidelines and laws of education be the same [everywhere] so that all humankind are given the same education. This means education and nurturing must be the same in all schools. All elements and methods must be the same.
Abdul Baha, Khatabat (Tehran), vol. 2, p. 148

This method has not been implemented in Bahai communities to any extent. Bahais receive the same tutoring and education that all non-Bahais receive. There exists no compulsion nor equality in the methods and degrees of education a Bahai receives. Since this teaching is completely impractical using the aforementioned format, Abdul Baha changed his mind and announced that there is no need for equal methods and degrees of education for all, rather education must be according to capacity:

Among other teachings and principles Bahaullah counsels the education of all members of society. No individual should be denied or deprived of intellectual training, although each should receive according to capacity. None must be left in the grades of ignorance, for ignorance is a defect in the human world. All mankind must be given a knowledge of science and philosophy-that is, as much as may be deemed necessary. All cannot be scientists and philosophers, but each should be educated according to his needs and deserts.
Abdul Baha, The Promulgation of Universal Peace, p.108

There is nothing exciting or outstanding about this order. All systems of education have been and still are based on the capacity of the student. How Abdul Baha hadn’t come by this order in the first place-with all his superhuman knowledge-is a question that the Bahais must answer.

2- The Babi Meaning of Education
The predecessor of Bahaullah, had he succeeded in spreading his creed, would have limited education to a few mere topics uttered in his own books. For he had given orders to destroy all non-Babi books ("Chapter six of the sixth unit which is about destroying all books but those that have been written or will be written about this order (meaning the Bab’s creed)," The Bab, Farsi Bayan, unit 6, chap. 6), had prohibited teaching anything but the Bayan ("Teaching a book other than the book of Bayan is not allowed unless it has in it what is related to theology (kalam). [Teaching] those [sciences] which have been invented such as logic (mantiq), principles [of Jurisprudence] (usul), and other [sciences], is not permitted for those who have faith," The Bab, Farsi Bayan, unit 4, chap. 10), and had prohibited owning more than nineteen books ("You have been prohibited in the Bayan from having more than nineteen books. If you do so, you will be fined 19 mithqals of gold," The Bab, Arabic Bayan, unit 11, chap. 7). The leader of a creed that goes about claiming that a single letter from these laws is more dear to him than everything that is in the skies and the earth ("I [swear by] He who in His hand is my soul and my essence, a single letter from the Bayan is dearer to me than everything that is in the heavens and the earth," Asad-Allah Fazil Mazandarani, Asrar al-athar khususi, vol. 5, p. 333), cannot exactly boast about being a promoter of education.

3- Education and Nurturing Will Not Dispel Ignorance
In the Bahai creed the criterion for ignorance and non-ignorance is not education. The criterion is accepting Bahaism or rejecting it. We will repeat here what we have quoted many times:

If today, someone grasps all of the knowledge on earth but stops at the word ‘yes’ (meaning does not become a Bahai), the Lord will not pay attention to him (ladi l-haqq madhkur na) and he will be considered as the most ignorant amongst the people.
Bahaullah, Iqtidarat wa chand lauh digar, p. 111

From now on nobody is to be called knowledgeable, except those who have decorated themselves with the garment of this New Affair (meaning those who have become Bahais).
Bahaullah, Badi, pp. 138-139

The general criterion is what we mentioned and any soul who has success in it, meaning recognizes and realizes the Sunrise of Manifestation (meaning himself), will be mentioned in the Divine Book as someone who possesses reason or else he will be (mentioned as) ignorant even if he himself thinks that his reason equals that of the whole world.
(`Abd al-Hamid Ishraq Khawari, Ma’idiy-i asimani (Tehran: Mu’assisiyi Milli Matbu`at Amri, 129 Badi), vol. 7, p. 160. In the scanned image of this book available at reference.bahai.org this page has been incorrectly replaced with the same page from vol. 8 of the book. The typed file in Microsoft Word format does not have this error)

4- The Outcome of the Education Bahai Leaders Received
As we showed in Chapter 4, the result of the education Bahai leaders received was the utterance of facts that were contrary to established sciences like physics, history, biology, and astrology. For example, they believe aliens live on all stars and planets, some creatures are created by spontaneous generation, and that Bahaullah was the creator of multiple Gods.

5- The Manners of Bahaullah and Abdul Baha as Two Examples of Bahai Education and Nurturing
Bahaullah’s manners are a clear example of the intended result of Bahai education and nurturing. He called those who opposed him donkeys and called his brother polytheist, calf, scarab (dung beetle), tyrant, and Satan. He even went as far as calling non-Bahais bastards and animals.
(Ref:"Oh you donkeys! Whatever God says is the truth and will not become void by the words of the polytheists," Bahaullah, Badi, p. 174.

"When Mirza Yahya Azal started opposing the works, deeds, and words of his esteemed brother (Bahaullah) in Edirne . . . he dropped down from his [high] stature and the rank of union and agreement [that he had with Bahaullah] and was gradually - in the tablets, works, and revelations [from Bahaullah] - referred to with codes, references, and names such as the polytheist, the calf, the scarab (dung beetle), the tyrant, the Satan, the devil, the foul swamp, the buzzing of a fly, and similar names," Asad-Allah Fazil Mazandarani, Asrar al-athar khu?u?i, vol. 5, p. 345-346.

"Whoever denies this apparent exalted luminous grace (meaning Bahaism), it is worthy that he asks his state from his mother and he will soon be returned to the bottom of hell," `Abd al-Hamid Ishraq Khawari, Ma’idiy-i asimani, vol. 4, pp. 355 and `Abd al-?amid Ishraq Khawari, Ganj-i shaygan, p. 78; "Whoever has the enmity of this servant (meaning Bahaullah) in his heart, certainly Satan has entered their mother’s bed," `Abd al-Hamid Ishraq Khawari, Ganj-i shaygan, p. 79. For example, "Today, according to the decree of the Point of Bayan (meaning the Bab), those individuals who turn away from this Novel Affair (meaning Bahaism) are deprived of the garb of being called and described [as humans?] and are assembled and mentioned as animals in the presence of God," Bahaullah, Badi, p. 213.)

We should point out again that this degree of manners and politeness emanates from the same Bahaullah that says:

Politeness is one of mankind’s traits that distinguishes him from other [creatures]. He who has no success in [being polite] then his demise certainly has-and will have-priority over his existence.
Bahaullah, Badi, p. 203-204

Abdul Baha followed his father’s example and used the same rude trend of name-calling towards his opponents:

They are senile like arrogant fools and not seashells full of gems. They are ecstatic from the smell of garbage like dung beetles and not from the scent of a flower of gardens. They are lowly earthworms buried beneath the great earth not high flying birds. They are bats of darkness not the searchlights of clear horizons. They always make excuses and like ravens, have nested in the landfills of fall (autumn) . . . so you Oh true friend and spiritual helper . . . attack these unjust foxes and like a high soaring eagle drive away these hateful ravens from this field.
Abdul Baha, Makatib (Egypt), vol. 1, pp. 442-443.

The words of Abdul Baha best describe this situation:

We should be fair. How can we expect a person that has failed in nurturing his children, spouse, and family to succeed in nurturing the people of the world? Is there any doubt or uncertainty about this issue? By God, no!
Abdul Baha, Makatib (Egypt), vol. 2, p. 182.

How can someone be a promoter of universal compulsory education when he fails to educate himself and his children?! According to Abdul Baha, the validity of a prophet’s claim can be verified by observing his ability in educating and nurturing human kind:

Prophets are public teachers. If we want to see that prophets are teachers we must independently seek the truth. If [prophets] nurture the souls and take them from the depths of ignorance to the peaks of knowledge, then they are surely true prophets.
`Abd al-Hamid Ishraq Khawari, Payam-i malakut, pp. 203-204.

6- Bahais Must be Educated Only in Bahai Schools
Abdul Baha gives strict orders to his followers to not send their children to non-Bahai schools:

It is absolutely prohibited for the children of the friends to go to the schools of others (meaning non-Bahais).
Abdul Baha, Makatib (probably Tehran), vol. 5, p. 170.

Is this the meaning of the Oneness of Humanity and not having prejudice? Why is this distinction made between Bahais and non-Bahais?

What is more interesting is the fact that Abdul Baha, as usual, did not mind not practicing what he preached. Although he strictly ordered Bahais to not enroll their children in non-Bahai schools, he enrolled Shoghi in non-Bahai schools himself:

It was here that Shoghi Effendi had a very significant dream which he recounted to me and which I wrote down. He said that when he was nine or ten years old, living with his nurse in this house and attending school in Haifa, he dreamed that he and another child, an Arab schoolmate, were in the room in which 'Abdu'l-Baha used to receive His guests in the house in Akka . . .
Ruhiyyih Rabbani, The Priceless Pearl (London: Bahai Publishing Trust, 1969), p. 16.

This trend continued until Shoghi finished high school and college:

Shoghi Effendi entered the best school in Haifa, the College des Freres, conducted by the Jesuits. He told me he had been very unhappy there. Indeed, I gathered from him that he never was really happy in either school or university. In spite of his innately joyous nature, his sensitivity and his background - so different from that of others in every way - could not but set him apart and give rise to many a heart-ache; indeed, he was one of those people whose open and innocent hearts, keen minds and affectionate nature seem to combine to bring upon them more shocks and suffering in life than is the lot of most men. Because of his unhappiness in this school 'Abdu'l-Baha decided to send him to Beirut where he attended another Catholic school as a boarder, and where he was equally unhappy. Learning of this in Haifa the family sent a trusted Baha'i woman to rent a home for Shoghi Effendi in Beirut and take care of and wait on him. It was not long before she wrote to his father that he was very unhappy at school, would refuse to go to it sometimes for days, and was getting thin and run down. His father showed this letter to 'Abdu'l-Baha Who then had arrangements made for Shoghi Effendi to enter the Syrian Protestant College, which had a school as well as a university, later known as the American College in Beirut, and which the Guardian entered when he finished what was then equivalent to the high school.
Ruhiyyih Rabbani, The Priceless Pearl, p. 17.

The articles have been based on the book "Avaze Dohol" - the Beating of the Drum by Masoud Basiti, Zahra Moradi.



blog comments powered by Disqus
   

Bookmark and Share | GET RSS

A FREE ONLINE MAGAZINE ON THE EVENTS IN THE WORLD OF BAHAIS
CLICK TO SUBSCRIBE

» Bab - Life and Times
» Bab v/s Holy Prophet
» Bab v/s Imam Mahdi
---------------------------------
» Key Bahai Teachings
» Bahai Principles Explained
» Bahaullah - Prophet or God?
---------------------------------
» Human Equality in Bahais
» Advancing Status of Women
» Fallacy of Gender Equality
» Unreasonableness of The Faith
---------------------------------
» Sects of Bahais
---------------------------------
» Unity of God - Analysis
» Prophethood - Analysis
» Prophethood in Quran
» Prophethood as per Bahais
» Day of Judgement - Analysis
» Fatwas for Bahais
» Fatwas from Malaysia
» Fatwas from Saudi Arabia
» Fatwas from Iran
» Fatwas from Al Azhar
» More Fatwas - Bahai Faith
---------------------------------
» Bahai Census Fraud
» Bahais Are Banned Everywhere
» Bahai Census - Iran
» Bahai Census - India
» Bahai Census - Russia
---------------------------------
» UHJ: Failed Prophecy
» Another Failed Prophecy
» Another Missing Prophecy
» 5 Lies of Abdul Baha
» The Shiah Viewpoint
» Name of Imam Mahdi
» Birth of Imam Mahdi
---------------------------------
» Books Section
» Videos Section
» BahaiTimes.com (Urdu)
---------------------------------
» God Passes By: Analysis
» Traveller's Narrative
» Some Answered Questions
» More Books
---------------------------------
» Twelve Bahai Principles
Free online magazine for updates in the Bahai World. Subscribe today!

---------------------------------

Aqdas in Hiding?
Bahai Fundamentalism
Understanding Laws


---------------------------------

BahaiAwareness on Facebook

---------------------------------
» Why This Website
» Readers View
» Give Feedback
» Sitemap